Skip to content
Legal Business
Twitter Logo Email Icon Youtube Circle Icon Facebook Circle Icon LinkedIn Icon Google+ Circle Icon
Newsletter Subscribe App Trial
Menu
  • Blog
    • BriefcaseDealwatch: Latham and Bakers handle agriculture merger as Weil and Kirkland land fintech financingCharles Avery
    • liversidge_suzanneUS expansion drives record revenue at Kennedys as Weightmans’ profits soar 25%Megan Mayers
    • Beautiful,Aerial,View,Over,Sofia,,The,Capital,Of,BulgariaInternational round-up: Ashurst pursues American dream with Texas opening as Eversheds expands in BulgariaTom Baker
    • City of LondonRevolving Doors: Paul Hastings adds two as McDermott boosts energy expertiseMegan Mayers
    • jones_jonathan‘Holding yourself accountable’: Squire Patton Boggs commits to net zero by 2035 with new ESG strategyCharles Avery
    • More Blogs
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Analysis
      • Deals Yearbook 2022 Cover FeatureAccess your print copy online – Deals Yearbook 2022
      • lb307_issue_menuGlobal London 2022 – contents
      • global london spread draft 2Global London Overview: Power plays
      • arbitration_harriet_fosterThe next generation of arbitration
      • international_womens_day‘Get the credit you deserve’ – top female partners on breaking biases and inspiring role models
      • sfoDisputes Yearbook 2022: Staying alive
      • natasha-harrisonBoies Don’t Cry
      • risk road signs ideaRisk management and professional indemnity survey 2022: Do the right thing
      • hsf_maslen-stannage_dagostinoHerbert Smith Freehills: Between two peaks
      • shutterstock_761559577 [Converted]The business of saving lives
      • LB305 p22-23 Legalease Research Services.inddLegalease Research Services: Held to account
        • Law firm financial data

          Access the full range of Legal Business financial reports, including  The LB100 and Global 100 – comprehensive coverage of the largest law firms in the world by revenue.

          Disputes hub


          Head to the LB Disputes hub for focused Disputes coverage, including news, events, analysis, comment and the latest Disputes Yearbook.

      • LB308 – issue menu
      • The ESG report
      • Access your print copy online – LB308
      • The ESG report – Overview: Turning on a greenback
      • The ESG report – Russia: All bite, no bark
      • The ESG report – Diversity and inclusion: A false start?
      • More analysis
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Insight
      • Law Tech: GC readers manualSponsored briefing: Legal tech – Too much of a good thing?Guest Blog
      • Tunnel diverThe New GC Toolkit: New game, new rules, new playersLegal Business
      • banks_peter_partnershipThe Path to Partnership: A Special ReportLegal Business
      • digital mapInternational Arbitration Insight: Bigger, longer, more complicatedJames Wood
      • Brexit close to finalThe edge of the cliff – Brexit response for worried GCsJames Wood
    • More Insight
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Comment
        • lb302_widget_esgTarget on your back – the rise and fall of the ESG lawyer?
        • Target on your back – the rise and fall of the ESG lawyer?
        • The profession must not let yesterday’s ESG news turn into today’s chip paper
        • The Last Word: Best foot forward
        • Guest comment: How are law firms retaining the top talent?
        • ESG – What is it good for?
        • Time for a reality check on salaries
      • More Comment
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • News review
      • ldl_jeff_twentymanLife During Law: Jeff TwentymanMegan Mayers
      • stephenson_harwoodThe big stories of the past two monthsMegan Mayers
      • Ropes & Gray; LB278 Oct/Nov 2017Strategic recruitment: Ropes makes triple private equity swoop as Latham loses energy partner to MilbankTom Baker
      • Miami,,Florida,Skyline,And,Bay,At,Sunset,Seen,Through,PalmThe American dream: US firms in expansion mode amid wave of international office openingsCharles Avery
      • royal_courts_justiceGerrard revelations and Ince restaurant-gate pose ethical quandaries for professionTom Baker
    • More news review
      • Crisis management

        Law firm coverage of crisis management amidst the Covid-19 pandemic

    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • International
        • Africa
            • Doha,,Qatar,-,November,24,2021:,Fifa,World,Cup,Qatar,2022Middle East and North Africa focus: The competitive edge
            • Aerial,Of,Skyline,Of,Maputo,-,Capital,City,Of,Mozambique,Africa focus: Rising again?
            • Empty,Wooden,Deck,Table,Over,Mosaic,Ornament,Wall,BackgroundMiddle East Focus: Light on the horizon
            • GC Powerlist Africa Teams

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Africa

        • Cyprus
            • Cyprus doveA new hope for Cyprus’s recession-battered lawyers
            • Cyprus flag puzzleCyprus: Picking up the pieces
            • black dog howling at grungey Cyprus flagReturn of the black dog – Hard times return for Cyprus’ legal community
            • GC Powerlist: Greece and Cyprus Teams

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Cyprus

        • Germany
          • Berlin,Brandenburg,Gate,,Berlin,,GermanyEuro Elite Germany: Bouncing back
          • Germany_5Germany focus: Age of independence
          • germanyleadimgHow the dust settles – Germany’s profession is forever changed but singular still
          • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Germany

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Deutschland

        • Iberia
          • PLMJ_Logo_H.S2.POS.CMYKSponsored briefing: How the Climate Law may change the Portuguese economy
          • PrintIberia focus: Banking on Success
          • PrintLetter from Iberia – Despite global meltdown, local lawyers remain upbeat
          • GC Powerlist: Iberia Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Portugal

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Spain

        • Ireland
            • PrintIreland focus: Riding it out
            • no_luck_required_ireland_desert_shamrockIreland: No luck required
            • DublinIreland: Follow the money
            • GC Powerlist: Ireland

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Ireland

        • Israel
            • PrintIsrael focus: Land of milk and honey
            • Tel AvivIsrael: Anti-fragile
            • Man walking on tightrope over Tel AvivIn the game – Israeli law firms embrace risks to secure the tech icons of tomorrow
            • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Israel

        • Italy
          • PrintThe Italian report – Midway upon the journey of our life
          • Italian astrology sceneThe Euro Elite: Italy – And yet it moves
          • Sepia Trevi foutain sceneRenaissance style – the battle to modernise Italy’s legal elite
          • GC Powerlist: Italy Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Italy

        • Malta
          • Aerial,View,Early,Morning,At,Sunrise,Of,Lady,Of,MountMalta focus: Grey skies turn to blue – the Malta report
          • PrintLife in a bubble – the Malta report
          • maltaMalta – Island Haven
          • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Malta

        • Middle East
            • Doha,,Qatar,-,November,24,2021:,Fifa,World,Cup,Qatar,2022Middle East and North Africa focus: The competitive edge
            • Empty,Wooden,Deck,Table,Over,Mosaic,Ornament,Wall,BackgroundMiddle East Focus: Light on the horizon
            • PrintThe Middle East: The rough with the crude
            • GC Powerlist: Middle East

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Middle East

        • Nordics
          • Nordic_07032022Nordics focus: High-value and strong values
          • nordics bridgeNordics: Northern Lights
          • Nordic rivals
          • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Europe

        • Offshore
          • uk_offshore_posterUK Offshore report: Keeping a weather eye
          • Palm,Tree,Leaves,Cast,Shadow,On,An,Orange,Textured,ConcreteCaribbean Offshore Report: The vital signs
          • PrintShoring up – the Offshore report
        • Southern and Eastern Europe
            • Sponsored profile: Gajski, Grlic, Prka & Partners, Zagreb, Croatia
            • Southern and Eastern Europe – A different hue
            • Croatia – ups and downs
        • Switzerland
            • Prager DreifussSponsored practice area spotlight: Insolvency and restructuring: Combining unique skills to achieve a successful outcome
            • Bouncing back SwitzerlandSwitzerland focus: Bouncing back
            • Aerial,View,Of,Zurich,City,Center,With,Famous,St.,PeterSwitzerland focus: Still standing
            • GC Powerlist: Switzerland

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Switzerland

        • Turkey
          • PrintTurkey focus: Chronology of a crisis
          • PrintLegal perspectives from Turkey
          • asc_law_20_yearSponsored briefing: Q&A with ASC Law’s senior management
          • GC Powerlist: Turkey Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Turkey

        • Euro Elite 2022
          • euro_elite_coverEuro Elite 2022 – Contents
          • euro_elite_main_tableEuro Elite 2022: Main table
          • Vilnius,,Lithuania,,Eastern,Europe.,Modern,Office,Buildings,Skyscrapers,In,BusinessEuro Elite Baltics: Closer together
          • Amsterdam,,Holland,-,August,24,,2019:,Old,City,,Amsterdam,AtEuro Elite Benelux: Full steam ahead
          • Budapest SunetEuro Elite CEE: The middle ground
          • Paris,,France.,Panoramic,View,From,Arc,De,Triomphe.,Eiffel,TowerEuro Elite France: Vive l’autonomie
          • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • In-House
      • spillett_wayneThe Client profile: Wayne Spillett, VodafoneTom Baker
      • Malpensa,Airport,,Italy,-,May,21,2020:,Part,Of,TheThe Client profile: easyJetMegan Mayers
      • Elisabeth Sullivan, Waterstones, LB306, February 2022The Client profile: Elisabeth Sullivan, WaterstonesTom Baker
      • Logo for the GC Powerlist Series

        Powerlists

        Nominations

      • Available Now…

        GC Powerlist UK 2020: The Change Agenda

        The GCs and in-house legal teams in the UK making a major contribution to positive change, either at an industry or sector level

        GC Powerlist: Turkey 2019

        The most influential and innovative in-house teams working in Turkey…

    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Awards
      • MPP8074Photos from The Legal Business Awards
      • MPP8091Sponsors
      • Contacts
  • Events
  • Covid-19
Analysis > Disputes Yearbook 2021

Hot topics

Snapshots of the most talked about issues concerning the London dispute resolution market today

Posted on 30 April 2021 10:00am10 June 2021 18:09pm
Tom Baker
Dispute resolution Disputes Yearbook 2021

SFO in the spotlight once again after stuttering investigations

Now a few years into the Lisa Osofsky era of the Serious Fraud Office (SFO), the jury is still out on the agency’s performance.

There have been successes: white-collar crime lawyers agree that the SFO’s near-€1bn deferred prosecution agreement (DPA) with Airbus in January 2020 was a solid achievement, with Stewarts’ fraud partner David Savage praising the international co-operation involved in securing the plea deal.

As of March 2021, the SFO had also successfully prosecuted four former oil executives as part of the wide-ranging Unaoil investigation, which uncovered over $17m worth of bribes paid to secure $1.7bn worth of contracts for Unaoil and its clients.

However these successes are increasingly fading in the rear-view mirror, with recent wins few and far between. The agency’s reputation was not helped by the unceremonious closing of its three-year bribery probe into British American Tobacco (BAT) in January, which drew ire from commentators. Founding partner of Stokoe Partnership Solicitors, Bambos Tsiattalou, says: ‘Yet another Serious Fraud Office investigation has collapsed. Its investigation into British American Tobacco began over three years ago and it has not been able to build a case strong enough to secure a result in that time. Better judgement should be exercised before such huge investigations
are embarked upon.’

But perhaps an even more damaging reverse was the February Supreme Court ruling that the SFO’s ‘Section 2’ powers, which compel companies to produce documents to assist investigations, can not be exerted over foreign companies that have no UK-based office. US engineering and construction company KBR successfully appealed to the Supreme Court on the basis that the SFO’s Section 2 powers were not extraterritorial in nature.

Savage comments: ‘The SFO tried to do something that pretty clearly did not have an extraterritorial effect. The Supreme Court said that you can’t just interpret a statute in any way that suits your needs.’

In future, the SFO will still be able to request such documentation, but will have to go via the mutual legal assistance route, which is recognised as being much slower. As Savage dryly notes: ‘More than the logistical issue, this is now a reputational issue for the SFO.’

So what does the SFO need? Savage speculates that a leadership shakeup or a refreshed approach to investigations is in order: ‘They have taken a general view that they will stop investigations if they feel they do not have enough evidence, which perhaps isn’t bullish enough.’

But one Magic Circle white-collar partner claims that ‘reports of the SFO’s death have been greatly exaggerated’ before identifying what they consider to be the key issue: ‘They’re dealing with legacy cases, but what they’re not doing is opening new investigations. I’m not quite sure what they are doing. When this crop comes to an end I don’t know what’s next for them.’

However if there is a lifeline for the agency, it may come oddly from the Covid-19 pandemic, which is sure to produce a healthy wave of fraud work in the next couple of years.

Masterclass in virtual justice as FCA wins Supreme Court Covid-19 test case

A ruling with profound implications for businesses struggling to survive during the Covid-19 pandemic, the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) coronavirus business interruption insurance test case was also a fine example of virtual justice.

The cause sought to determine whether companies have valid business disruption insurance claims as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic. In just seven months, right in the heart of the first wave of the pandemic in the UK, the case went from issuance to a detailed 112-page Supreme Court judgment thanks largely to video and other technology enabling remote hearings.

Allen & Overy partner Lawson Caisley represented insurer Hiscox on the case, and describes the slick virtual procedure as a ‘great advert for the English courts.’ Stewarts partner Mo Bhaskran hails the ‘astonishing’ process and notes how vital it was that a critical matter effecting hundreds of thousands of policy holders was resolved so expediently.

In fact, despite the case being a major loss for insurers, who will now inevitably have to pay out large sums, the swift decision was appreciated. Says Caisley: ‘There’s no real narrative of insurers being dragged kicking and screaming to court. In fact it was a good exercise in co-operation. This was considered an issue of general importance for insurers and they appreciate the court’s clarity.’

Simmons & Simmons partner Felix Zimmermann represented insurer Argenta Holdings on the case, which he describes as a ‘record breaking-quick procedure.’ He also praises the good-natured collaboration shown by both the claimant and defendant legal teams throughout, and notes that everyone ‘worked around the clock, from 6am to midnight most days.’

Despite this, Bhaskran emphasises the importance of the decision, which will affect 370,000 policyholders: ‘Insurance policies are not easy to write. Hiscox prides itself on clear policies in plain English, but they will have to take this one on the chin. From the policyholders’ point of view, they will say “we have got a business interruption policy related to disease.” But Hiscox would never have expected this to have impacted on Covid. It was only every intended to cover businesses from a small-scale event close to the local premises.’

Related  Sponsored briefing: Corporate criminal liability in Germany

And in further bad news for the insurers, Zimmermann notes that the decision will inevitably lead to follow-on professional negligence claims against insurers. Claimant firms will of course welcome such news however, with Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan partner Boris Bronfentrinker observing: ‘This FCA judgement will definitely trigger more litigation.’

Practical implications of post-Brexit disputes

It has been a topic looming over the disputes market since the seminal Brexit vote in 2016 – to what extent will the UK’s withdrawal from the European Union affect its desirability as a disputes forum? For a few years this has been largely a predictive exercise, but since officially leaving the bloc, there are real-world experiences to assess.

Tom Hibbert

‘The reality is that commercial contracts still plump for English law on much more of a regular basis than anywhere else. All the advantages London had, it pretty much still has.’
Tom Hibbert, RPC

Outside of the worries around the practical implications of being outside of the EU, some counsel had feared that Brexit would leave clients concerned (rightly or wrongly) and therefore the UK would decrease in desirability as a disputes hub. However RPC head of commercial disputes Tom Hibbert robustly dispels such a suggestion:

‘People choose London for a variety of reasons and being in the EU has always been one, although not a very substantial one. Are you going to prefer London or Frankfurt? Well, it’s London obviously, because we’ve got a much better infrastructure for big litigation. The reality is that commercial contracts still plump for English law on much more of a regular basis than anywhere else. All the advantages London had, it pretty much still has. London has had the pre-eminent commercial court in the world for the last 300 years. The idea that was driven by our membership of the EU is a bit silly.’

This is a widely-shared view in the market, and therefore most concerns are in relation to the practical implications. A potentially significant issue in this regard stems from the UK’s absence from both the Lugano Convention and the Brussels (Recast) Regulation, both of which ensure that parties’ contractual choice of jurisdiction is enforced and that judgments are recognisable and enforceable across the EU.

‘Brexit is not a cause for uncertainty or complication but if it results in international companies deciding to agree in their contracts to arbitrate in another jurisdiction just in case, then that will affect the flow of international arbitrations into London.’ William Cecil, Haynes and Boone

Therefore in April 2020 the UK applied to join the Lugano Convention, but this relies on the approval of every member of the Convention, which includes the EU itself. Some in the market were relaxed about this, whereas others were more cautious. Simmons & Simmons litigation partner Elizabeth Williams said: ‘This poses a real risk to the procedural aspects of commencing litigation in this jurisdiction. People think that us joining Lugano will be a rubber-stamping exercise, but that’s not the case.’ She added that the EU taking a long time to reveal its position on the UK’s application was a worrying sign.

Sure enough, as the Disputes Yearbook went to press, the pessimists’ worst fears were realised when the EU opted to veto the UK’s ascension to the Lugano Convention. While this is sure to be bad news for the City’s litigators, this new lack of wide enforceability is likely to be quietly welcomed by London’s arbitrators who are largely immune to such concerns and therefore predict a potential large-scale client shift from litigation to arbitration. Head of Haynes and Boone’s London dispute resolution team, William Cecil, notes that arbitration awards are enforced internationally under the New York Convention (which has over 150 signatory countries), which is not impacted by the UK’s EU membership.

He asserts that London is and will remain ‘the leading seat for arbitration’, but he recognises the danger in clients not receiving this message: ‘Brexit is not a cause for uncertainty or complication but if it results in international companies deciding to agree in their contracts to arbitrate in another jurisdiction just in case, then that will affect the flow of international arbitrations into London.’ LB

Return to the Disputes Yearbook 2021 menu

Share
Tweet
Share
Reddit
WhatsApp
Email
  • Subscriber Login

  • Latest Issue

    LB308 cover

    • The ESG report – Viewing the legal elite through the lens of responsible business
    • The ESG report – Overview: Turning on a greenback
    • The ESG report – Russia: All bite, no bark
    • The ESG report – Diversity and inclusion: A false start?
    • ‘I’ve acted for every villain you can name’: Lessons in ESG from its trailblazers – and how to dodge the greenwashing bullet
    • Latin America focus: Brave new world
    • Malta focus: Grey skies turn to blue – the Malta report
    • Middle East and North Africa focus: The competitive edge
    • Leader: Target on your back – the rise and fall of the ESG lawyer?
    • Pritchard: The profession must not let yesterday’s ESG news turn into today’s chip paper
    • Life During Law: Jeff Twentyman
    • The Client profile: Wayne Spillett, Vodafone
    • The Last Word: Best foot forward
  • Related by topic

    Sponsored briefing: Catching up with the world: Korea updates its conflict of laws
  • Related by topic

    MoloLamken
    Sponsored briefing: The antitrust challenge to Big Tech
  • Most read this week

    1. A class act: Skadden and the industry mourn death of M&A icon Scott Simpson
    2. Revolving Doors: Proskauer and Weil add to City restructuring ranks as Linklaters makes real estate finance hire
    3. Dealwatch: Elite firms act on major private credit deal as playmakers pounce on TigerRisk acquisition
    4. Revolving Doors: Latham loses energy partner to Milbank as Global 100 firms take partners from each other
    5. Osborne Clarke adds over €60m to top line amid buoyant financials

    Analysis

    • LB308 – issue menu

    • Access your print copy online – LB308

    • The ESG report

    • The ESG report – Overview: Turning on a greenback

    • The ESG report – Russia: All bite, no bark

    • The ESG report – Diversity and inclusion: A false start?

    • ‘I’ve acted for every villain you can name’: Lessons in ESG from its trailblazers – and how to dodge the greenwashing bullet

    Useful Links

    • The Legal 500
    • Comparative Guides
    • GC Magazine
    • GC Powerlist
    • In-house Lawyer Magazine
    • The Lex 100
    • Legalease Law Journals
    • Legalease Publishing
    • Practical Lawyer

    © 2022 Legal Business Magazine

    Legalease Ltd, 188 Fleet Street, London, EC4A 2AG

    T: +44 (0)20 7396 9313 | E: subscriptions@legalease.co.uk

    About & Contacts | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Subscriptions