Skip to content
Legal Business
Twitter Logo Email Icon Youtube Circle Icon Facebook Circle Icon LinkedIn Icon Google+ Circle Icon
Newsletter Subscribe App Trial
Menu
  • Blog
    • Morrisons supermarketDealwatch: Ashurst and Travers double up on McColl’s and Ideagen acquisitions as Freshfields energises offshore wind dealCharles Avery
    • Royal Courts of Justice, LondonDechert condemns former partner Gerrard after High Court rules the firm breached ENRC client dutyTom Baker
    • Lawyer MartRevolving Doors: BCLP hires Brown Rudnick restructuring duo as Greenberg bolsters white-collar practiceMegan Mayers
    • Nathalie Tidman 2022Comment: A personality crisis and the great WFH salary cut brouhahaNathalie Tidman
    • Ince & CoInce in firing line over ‘inappropriate’ restaurant behaviour allegationsTom Baker
    • More Blogs
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Analysis
      • lb307_issue_menuGlobal London 2022 – contents
      • global london spread draft 2Global London Overview: Power plays
      • arbitration_harriet_fosterThe next generation of arbitration
      • international_womens_day‘Get the credit you deserve’ – top female partners on breaking biases and inspiring role models
      • sfoDisputes Yearbook 2022: Staying alive
      • natasha-harrisonBoies Don’t Cry
      • risk road signs ideaRisk management and professional indemnity survey 2022: Do the right thing
      • hsf_maslen-stannage_dagostinoHerbert Smith Freehills: Between two peaks
      • shutterstock_761559577 [Converted]The business of saving lives
      • LB305 p22-23 Legalease Research Services.inddLegalease Research Services: Held to account
        • Law firm financial data

          Access the full range of Legal Business financial reports, including  The LB100 and Global 100 – comprehensive coverage of the largest law firms in the world by revenue.

          Disputes hub


          Head to the LB Disputes hub for focused Disputes coverage, including news, events, analysis, comment and the latest Disputes Yearbook.

      • Deals Yearbook 2022: The next generation of dealmakers
      • Shining a light on the next generation of dealmakers
      • Marching on
      • Deals perspectives: Nallini Puri
      • Deals perspectives: Sylvia Andriessen
      • Deals perspectives: Samantha Thompson
      • More analysis
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Insight
      • Law Tech: GC readers manualSponsored briefing: Legal tech – Too much of a good thing?Guest Blog
      • Tunnel diverThe New GC Toolkit: New game, new rules, new playersLegal Business
      • banks_peter_partnershipThe Path to Partnership: A Special ReportLegal Business
      • digital mapInternational Arbitration Insight: Bigger, longer, more complicatedJames Wood
      • Brexit close to finalThe edge of the cliff – Brexit response for worried GCsJames Wood
    • More Insight
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Comment
        • lb302_widget_esgESG – What is it good for?
        • ESG – What is it good for?
        • Time for a reality check on salaries
        • The Last Word: Broad stripes and bright stars
        • Lessons in management: Spoiler alert – it doesn’t get easier
        • Stronger together? Not really
        • The Last Word: Elite culture
      • More Comment
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • News review
      • alvarez_and_marsalSponsored briefing: As data breach becomes a battleground for class action litigation, companies need to take a risk-based approach to cyber securityGuest Blog
      • Moscow,City,Skyscraper,And,Skyline,Architecture,,Moscow,International,Business,FinancialConflict prompts Moscow exodus for Global 100 firms as Ukraine crisis takes its tollCharles Avery
      • ldl_diala_minottLife During Law: Diala MinottMegan Mayers
      • ПечатьLegal 500 data: The Legal 500 Global London rankingsGeorgina Stanley
      • Conyers_PMSc539Sponsored briefing: Utilising offshore structures for digital assetsGuest Blog
    • More news review
      • Crisis management

        Law firm coverage of crisis management amidst the Covid-19 pandemic

    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • International
        • Africa
            • Aerial,Of,Skyline,Of,Maputo,-,Capital,City,Of,Mozambique,Africa focus: Rising again?
            • Empty,Wooden,Deck,Table,Over,Mosaic,Ornament,Wall,BackgroundMiddle East Focus: Light on the horizon
            • African Union FlagAfrica focus: Africa first
            • GC Powerlist Africa Teams

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Africa

        • Cyprus
            • Cyprus doveA new hope for Cyprus’s recession-battered lawyers
            • Cyprus flag puzzleCyprus: Picking up the pieces
            • black dog howling at grungey Cyprus flagReturn of the black dog – Hard times return for Cyprus’ legal community
            • GC Powerlist: Greece and Cyprus Teams

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Cyprus

        • Germany
          • Berlin,Brandenburg,Gate,,Berlin,,GermanyEuro Elite Germany: Bouncing back
          • Germany_5Germany focus: Age of independence
          • germanyleadimgHow the dust settles – Germany’s profession is forever changed but singular still
          • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Germany

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Deutschland

        • Iberia
          • PLMJ_Logo_H.S2.POS.CMYKSponsored briefing: How the Climate Law may change the Portuguese economy
          • PrintIberia focus: Banking on Success
          • PrintLetter from Iberia – Despite global meltdown, local lawyers remain upbeat
          • GC Powerlist: Iberia Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Portugal

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Spain

        • Ireland
            • PrintIreland focus: Riding it out
            • no_luck_required_ireland_desert_shamrockIreland: No luck required
            • DublinIreland: Follow the money
            • GC Powerlist: Ireland

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Ireland

        • Israel
            • PrintIsrael focus: Land of milk and honey
            • Tel AvivIsrael: Anti-fragile
            • Man walking on tightrope over Tel AvivIn the game – Israeli law firms embrace risks to secure the tech icons of tomorrow
            • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Israel

        • Italy
          • PrintThe Italian report – Midway upon the journey of our life
          • Italian astrology sceneThe Euro Elite: Italy – And yet it moves
          • Sepia Trevi foutain sceneRenaissance style – the battle to modernise Italy’s legal elite
          • GC Powerlist: Italy Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Italy

        • Malta
          • PrintLife in a bubble – the Malta report
          • maltaMalta – Island Haven
          • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Malta

        • Middle East
            • Empty,Wooden,Deck,Table,Over,Mosaic,Ornament,Wall,BackgroundMiddle East Focus: Light on the horizon
            • PrintThe Middle East: The rough with the crude
            • RiyadhMiddle East: Mission unaccomplished
            • GC Powerlist: Middle East

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Middle East

        • Nordics
          • Nordic_07032022Nordics focus: High-value and strong values
          • nordics bridgeNordics: Northern Lights
          • Nordic rivals
          • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Europe

        • Offshore
          • uk_offshore_posterUK Offshore report: Keeping a weather eye
          • Palm,Tree,Leaves,Cast,Shadow,On,An,Orange,Textured,ConcreteCaribbean Offshore Report: The vital signs
          • PrintShoring up – the Offshore report
        • Southern and Eastern Europe
            • Sponsored profile: Gajski, Grlic, Prka & Partners, Zagreb, Croatia
            • Southern and Eastern Europe – A different hue
            • Ukraine – green shoots and uncertainty
        • Switzerland
            • Prager DreifussSponsored practice area spotlight: Insolvency and restructuring: Combining unique skills to achieve a successful outcome
            • Bouncing back SwitzerlandSwitzerland focus: Bouncing back
            • Aerial,View,Of,Zurich,City,Center,With,Famous,St.,PeterSwitzerland focus: Still standing
            • GC Powerlist: Switzerland

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Switzerland

        • Turkey
          • PrintTurkey focus: Chronology of a crisis
          • PrintLegal perspectives from Turkey
          • asc_law_20_yearSponsored briefing: Q&A with ASC Law’s senior management
          • GC Powerlist: Turkey Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Turkey

        • Euro Elite 2022
          • euro_elite_coverEuro Elite 2022 – Contents
          • euro_elite_main_tableEuro Elite 2022: Main table
          • Vilnius,,Lithuania,,Eastern,Europe.,Modern,Office,Buildings,Skyscrapers,In,BusinessEuro Elite Baltics: Closer together
          • Amsterdam,,Holland,-,August,24,,2019:,Old,City,,Amsterdam,AtEuro Elite Benelux: Full steam ahead
          • Budapest SunetEuro Elite CEE: The middle ground
          • Paris,,France.,Panoramic,View,From,Arc,De,Triomphe.,Eiffel,TowerEuro Elite France: Vive l’autonomie
          • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • In-House
      • Malpensa,Airport,,Italy,-,May,21,2020:,Part,Of,TheThe Client profile: easyJetMegan Mayers
      • Elisabeth Sullivan, Waterstones, LB306, February 2022The Client profile: Elisabeth Sullivan, WaterstonesTom Baker
      • Sarah-HolfordThe Client profile: Sarah Holford, Scania UKTom Baker
      • Logo for the GC Powerlist Series

        Powerlists

        Nominations

      • Available Now…

        GC Powerlist UK 2020: The Change Agenda

        The GCs and in-house legal teams in the UK making a major contribution to positive change, either at an industry or sector level

        GC Powerlist: Turkey 2019

        The most influential and innovative in-house teams working in Turkey…

    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Awards
      • MPP8074Photos from The Legal Business Awards
      • MPP8091Sponsors
      • Contacts
  • Events
  • Covid-19
Analysis > Disputes Yearbook 2018

Boutiques: Highly evolved

The increasingly Darwinian City disputes market has birthed a series of hugely-successful litigation specialists in recent years. Can they get to the top of the food chain?

Posted on 17 May 2018 09:30am17 May 2018 11:59am
Tom Baker
Disputes Yearbook 2018 Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & SullivanStewarts Litigation

With the disputes market evolving and clients becoming more discerning, it has been a phenomenal ten years for boutique law firms focused on litigation. The pressure on generalist, mid-market dispute teams has played towards this dynamic, leaving true contentious specialists increasingly going head-to-head with the traditional London elite.

A glance at the financial results of some of the main litigation specialists – Stewarts, Signature Litigation and Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan – shows dramatic increases in revenue amid a string of major cases.

But with the post-banking crisis malaise providing the ideal conditions to turn boutiques into a major part of the City disputes ecosystem, the question remains of whether the wide array of disputes specialists can hope to sustain this success.

Clive Zietman, head of commercial litigation at Stewarts, says ‘boutique’ is becoming a problematic word. Stewarts – styled as the UK’s largest disputes-led law firm – has amassed over 50 partners, and now covers a wide range of contentious and private client work.

Despite the firm’s dramatic headcount growth in recent years, Zietman argues the firm will remain a specialist shop. ‘Clients increasingly want horses for courses, whether that’s a one-stop-shop like Allen & Overy or a specialist firm like us. The firms that are really feeling it are those in the middle – the ones that are merging like Olswang and Nabarro. What is the unique selling point of Olswang?’

It is hard to fault Zietman’s assessment. Stewarts was a standout performer in last year’s Legal Business 100 (LB100) with turnover climbing 25% to £77.9m and profit per equity partner rising 19% to £1.9m. That meant revenue grew 123% over the space of five years and, as a result, the firm moved into the top half of the LB100 for the first time.

In 2018 Stewarts will have the culmination of its long-fought Tesco trial, in which it is representing over 125 institutional funds, which claim to have lost money as a result of the supermarket giant overstating its profits by £263m in October 2014. Further, Stewarts is keen to grow its ‘satellite’ practices, such as tax, arbitration and probates, all of which are in their infancy.

And on the subject of selling points, Zietman is bullish about what makes Stewarts stand out: ‘There’s a maturing on the part of corporate clients. They will test the market on experience, price, specialism and whether fees can be arranged on a contingency basis. They also want to know who understands funding. The big firms do not understand funding. They have a reticence because they are so used to the dogma of hourly-based billing. They make enough money as it is so they don’t see the need to entertain it.’

Clive Zietman

‘The firms that are really feeling it are those in the middle – the ones that are merging like Olswang and Nabarro. What is the unique selling point of Olswang?’
Clive Zietman, Stewarts

While there has been more consolidation in the mid-market in the last three years, there is little sign of dispute specialists looking to combine, despite an abortive discussion early last year between two of the most high-profile brands, Stewarts and Enyo Law.

Without a tie-up, the prospects for Enyo have aroused much discussion among peers. Formed by ex-Addleshaw Goddard partners Simon Twigden, Pietro Marino and Michael Green in 2010, Enyo was among the first of the litigation boutiques to really capture the professional imagination in London. Success was found in its initial years, picking up high-profile work such as acting for Russian oligarch Boris Berezovsky.

However, 2017 was relatively quiet, given the dramatic growth the firm had achieved in previous years. Outside of the launches of tax and insolvency practices instigated by hiring partners Fiona Walkinshaw and Louise Bell, from Deloitte and Olswang respectively, Enyo had a lower profile in domestic disputes. This was in part due to an increased focus on international clients and arbitration.

Related  'Huge opportunities': CMS launches in Hong Kong in Asia arbitration play

Enyo’s most recent LLP accounts for the 2016/17 financial year, filed in January, saw revenue slightly dip from £20.8m to £20.4m. Operating profit was down from £12.5m to £12.1m, but the firm’s highest-earning member received £3.5m, up on last year’s £3m remuneration. The key issues facing the firm over the next five years will be how it handles succession as highly-regarded figures like Twigden and Marino look to hand over to the next generation, and the tantalising possibility of a US tie-up must be considered.

A class apart

Quinn, of course, has become a category unto itself. The iconoclastic US disputes giant is far larger than any UK-bred peer and the firm has been singularly successful in recent years, including becoming one of the world’s most profitable law firms.

Quinn partner Ted Greeno argues that the calibre of the firm’s work is also a class apart. He asserts: ‘Very rarely do we see the other boutiques. We sit in a unique space in the market because we are competing at the top level internationally with the other top firms but only in one area.’

A marker of Quinn’s success, the firm posted a remarkable set of London financials in January, with revenues rising by a striking 61% to £71.9m.

A newer entrant gaining attention is Joseph Hage Aaronson (JHA). Established in March 2013, the tax and litigation specialist’s primary selling point is its prominent integration of barristers and solicitors on client-facing matters. At present, the firm can boast the services of Daniel Margolin QC and Tom Beazley QC, who are expected to collaborate with solicitors and be present from the very first client meeting.

Ted Greeno

‘Very rarely do we see the other boutiques. We sit in a unique space in the market.’
Ted Greeno, Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan

The firm has seen its headcount expand considerably since its inception, growing from ten staff to around 100 now. Of those 100, 50 are fee-earners and 13 are partners. Partner Michael Anderson says: ‘We don’t see Enyo or Stewarts as competitors; they do things slightly different. Nearly all of our work is high value and most of our clients are international. A lot of our work also has some kind of political context to it.’

JHA saw its revenues grow a robust 13% to £24.5m in the 2016/17 financial year, off the back of some marquee international cases. Among the larger mandates, the likes of which Anderson cited, was acting for OJSC Rosneft, the Russian energy firm battling sanctions imposed after Russia’s annexation of Crimea.

Growth has been similarly dramatic at Signature. The firm capped off a run of high-profile mandates to record a 16% uptick in revenue for the 2016/17 financial year. Among the cases was The Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) group action, in which the firm represented thousands of investors in a £4bn rights-issue dispute. Under Signature’s profit-sharing scheme, 21% of profits were paid out to staff.

Signature partner Graham Huntley, who led for the firm on the RBS case, comments: ‘We take the benefits of our simplicity and efficiency to offer clients lower-charging models. It would also have been a great shame if we hadn’t taken the opportunity of a blank sheet of paper to create a whole new economic and management model for law firms, which is what we did six years ago.’

Overall, boutiques occupy a clear place in the market that is increasingly inhospitable to generalists. The challenge ahead will be to work out how best to manage their growth and the inevitable governance challenges they will face, as they mature and initial founders take a step back.

But Zietman is predictably bullish about the position he and his peers have carved. ‘We won’t see a lot of firms rushing to move into our space. It takes a leap of faith to set up your own firm.’

tom.baker@legalease.co.uk

Return to the Disputes Yearbook 2018 menu

  • Subscriber Login

  • Latest Issue

    LB307 cover

    • Global London 2022
    • The next generation of arbitration
    • ‘Get the credit you deserve’ – top female partners on breaking biases and inspiring role models
    • Conflict prompts Moscow exodus for Global 100 firms as Ukraine crisis takes its toll
    • Turkey focus: Chronology of a crisis
    • Nordics focus: High-value and strong values
    • Leader: ESG – What is it good for?
    • Pritchard: Time for a reality check on salaries
    • Life During Law: Diala Minott
    • The Client profile: easyJet
    • The Last Word: Broad stripes and bright stars
  • Related by topic

    Disputes Yearbook 2018: Ready for its close up
  • Related by topic

    ‘Implications across the board’: Supreme Court clarifies professional negligence rules in landmark BPE Solicitors case
  • Related content

    RBS group action settles with Quinn, Stewarts and Mishcon claimants as Signature prepares for trial
    Quinn, Stewarts and Signature demand costs from Mishcon clients in RBS litigation saga
    Stewarts Law chases the American dream
  • Most read this week

    1. Ince in firing line over ‘inappropriate’ restaurant behaviour allegations
    2. The next generation of arbitration
    3. Dechert condemns former partner Gerrard after High Court rules the firm breached ENRC client duty
    4. Revolving doors: Four in three out for Squire as Ropes brings in private equity trio
    5. Comment: A personality crisis and the great WFH salary cut brouhaha

    Analysis

    • Deals Yearbook 2022: The next generation of dealmakers

    • Shining a light on the next generation of dealmakers

    • Marching on

    • Deals perspectives: Nallini Puri

    • Deals perspectives: Sylvia Andriessen

    • Deals perspectives: Samantha Thompson

    • LB307 – issue menu

    Useful Links

    • The Legal 500
    • Comparative Guides
    • GC Magazine
    • GC Powerlist
    • In-house Lawyer Magazine
    • The Lex 100
    • Legalease Law Journals
    • Legalease Publishing
    • Practical Lawyer

    © 2022 Legal Business Magazine

    Legalease Ltd, 188 Fleet Street, London, EC4A 2AG

    T: +44 (0)20 7396 9313 | E: subscriptions@legalease.co.uk

    About & Contacts | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Subscriptions