Skip to content
Legal Business
Twitter Logo Email Icon Youtube Circle Icon Facebook Circle Icon LinkedIn Icon Google+ Circle Icon
Newsletter Subscribe App Trial
Menu
  • Blog
    • los_angelesRevolving doors: A&O enters La La Land with group hire as DLA Piper lures former Freshfields finance chiefTom Baker
    • shropshire_tomRevolving doors: Linklaters senior partner candidate replaces Moriarty at Diageo as accountancy GC lands at ClydesTom Baker
    • thomas_sandy_reed_smithCoronavirus measures pay off for Reed Smith as revenue tops $1.3bn while profit soars Tom Baker
    • supreme_court‘Huge implications’: employment experts assess fallout from Supreme Court ruling against UberTom Baker
    • empson_morley_leading_professional_people_spotifyGuest comment: Balancing acts – partnership versus corporationGuest Blog
    • More Blogs
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Analysis
      • Print300 not out…the story of Legal Business spanning three decades
      • cog idea EKThe Euro Elite 2021: Keeping the cogs turning
      • main_table_euro_elite_cogsThe Euro Elite overview: Enduring endurance
      • Herbert Smith Freehills; Aug 2018Getting personal – perspectives on crisis management in the Covid-19 era
      • lb300_complete_coverAccess your print copy online – LB300
        • Law firm financial data

          Access the full range of Legal Business financial reports, including  The LB100 and Global 100 – comprehensive coverage of the largest law firms in the world by revenue.

          Disputes hub


          Head to the LB Disputes hub for focused Disputes coverage, including news, events, analysis, comment and the latest Disputes Yearbook.

      • LB300 – issue menu
      • Access your print copy online – LB300
      • 300 not out…the story of Legal Business spanning three decades
      • The Euro Elite 2021: Keeping the cogs turning
      • The Euro Elite overview: Enduring endurance
      • Euro Elite: Baltics – Small yet spirited
      • More analysis
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Insight
      • Law Tech: GC readers manualSponsored briefing: Legal tech – Too much of a good thing?Guest Blog
      • Tunnel diverThe New GC Toolkit: New game, new rules, new playersLegal Business
      • banks_peter_partnershipThe Path to Partnership: A Special ReportLegal Business
      • digital mapInternational Arbitration Insight: Bigger, longer, more complicatedJames Wood
      • Brexit close to finalThe edge of the cliff – Brexit response for worried GCsJames Wood
    • More Insight
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Comment
        • art deco-style 2020s airship in LondonLearning from the ghosts of decades past
        • Learning from the ghosts of decades past
        • Depressing end to Weinstein gagging order narrative means closure for none
        • The Last Word: So far so good?
        • Not a roaring start to the 2020s but bravery is key
        • Failings in Beckwith prosecution undermine #MeToo fight and muzzle regulator
        • The Last Word: Immovable objects
      • More Comment
    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • News review
      • ПечатьThe Legal 500 View: The rise of US firms from barbarians at the gate to London’s top tiersGeorgina Stanley
      • balasubramanian_anuLife During Law: Anu BalasubramanianThomas Alan
      • Conyers_PMSc539Sponsored briefing: Flexible and stable: The growing appeal of offshore SPACsGuest Blog
      • davitt_jones_bouldSponsored briefing: Are we on the cusp of an evolution in the legal sector, when collaborative ways of working between firms will become the norm?Guest Blog
      • ldl_samantha_mobleyLife During Law: Samantha MobleyNathalie Tidman
    • More news review
      • Crisis management

        Law firm coverage of crisis management amidst the Covid-19 pandemic

    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • International
        • Africa
            • suitcase with African stickersAfrica rising – Foreign firms strive to cover the booming continent
            • waking_the_elephant_africaLegal leaders in Africa: Waking the elephant
            • city railway illustrationLaying the foundations – lawyers scramble as demand for African infra booms
            • GC Powerlist Africa Teams

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Africa

        • Cyprus
            • Cyprus doveA new hope for Cyprus’s recession-battered lawyers
            • Cyprus flag puzzleCyprus: Picking up the pieces
            • black dog howling at grungey Cyprus flagReturn of the black dog – Hard times return for Cyprus’ legal community
            • GC Powerlist: Greece and Cyprus Teams

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Cyprus

        • Iberia
          • PrintLetter from Iberia – Despite global meltdown, local lawyers remain upbeat
          • madrid 3Letter from Iberia – Despite turbulent politics, Madrid lawyers sustain bullish mood
          • Richter ScaleIberia: Off the Richter scale
          • GC Powerlist: Iberia Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Portugal

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Spain

        • Ireland
            • no_luck_required_ireland_desert_shamrockIreland: No luck required
            • DublinIreland: Follow the money
            • Businessman running to DublinIreland: A case to make
            • GC Powerlist: Ireland

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Ireland

        • Israel
            • Tel AvivIsrael: Anti-fragile
            • Man walking on tightrope over Tel AvivIn the game – Israeli law firms embrace risks to secure the tech icons of tomorrow
            • Tel Aviv tech styleValue range – as the money pours in, can Israel takes its high-growth stars global?
            • The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Israel

        • Italy
          • PrintThe Italian report – Midway upon the journey of our life
          • Italian astrology sceneThe Euro Elite: Italy – And yet it moves
          • Sepia Trevi foutain sceneRenaissance style – the battle to modernise Italy’s legal elite
          • GC Powerlist: Italy Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Italy

        • Middle East
            • PrintThe Middle East: The rough with the crude
            • RiyadhMiddle East: Mission unaccomplished
            • Offshore oil rig with stock market overlayHolding steady – A turbulent Middle East market separates the committed from the faint-hearted
            • GC Powerlist: Middle East

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Middle East

        • Offshore
          • hot_air_balloon_covidUK offshore report: Staying afloat
          • virtual_handshakeCaribbean offshore report: End of the storm?
          • card gameGlobal offshore – Stick or twist for the sector’s leaders
        • Russia
            • bear on russian flag illustrationRousing the bear – Russian counsel force to hunt in new places
            • frozen cityThe Russia report: A new thaw?
            • Propaganda-style posterAboard the propaganda train – sweat and spin amid a turbulent Russian market
            • GC Powerlist: Russia Teams

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Russia

        • Southern and Eastern Europe
            • Sponsored profile: Gajski, Grlic, Prka & Partners, Zagreb, Croatia
            • Southern and Eastern Europe – A different hue
        • Switzerland
            • Welcome to SwitzerlandA very clear shift – Remaking the Swiss economy
            • lb297_prager_dreifuss_collageSponsored spotlight: Dispute resolution: Strategic case management with legal acumen
            • Eu rock with Swiss flag in creviceSwitzerland – Between a rock and a hard place
            • GC Powerlist: Switzerland

              The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Switzerland

        • Turkey
          • turkey5Turkey – Back from the brink
          • bridging-the-gapTurkey – Bridging the Gap
          • turkey2Leading ladies
          • GC Powerlist: Turkey Teams

            The Legal 500 law firm rankings: Turkey

        • The Euro Elite 2021
          • Wonderful,Evening,Scenic,Summer,Panorama,Of,Tallinn,,EstoniaEuro Elite: Baltics – Small yet spirited
          • Panoramic,Aerial,View,Of,The,Central,Part,Of,Brussels,,TheEuro Elite: Benelux – Reasons to be cheerful
          • Ada,,Gazela,Bridges,,Belgrade,Waterfront,,Government,Of,Serbia,,Sava,RiverEuro Elite: CEE – Finding the middle ground
          • Aerial,View,Of,Paris,With,Eiffel,Tower,,FranceEuro Elite: France – Shining lights
          • Sunset,Over,Frankfurt,SkylineEuro Elite: Germany – Flight to quality
          • Aerial,View,Plaza,De,Cibeles,In,Madrid,In,A,BeautifulEuro Elite: Iberia – Stronger together
          • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • In-House
      • Philip PriceLeadership and developmentLegal Business
      • Vincent CordoOperations and procurementLegal Business
      • Dan KayneInterview with… Dan KayneLegal Business
      • Logo for the GC Powerlist Series

        Powerlists

        Nominations

      • Available Now…

        GC Powerlist UK 2020: The Change Agenda

        The GCs and in-house legal teams in the UK making a major contribution to positive change, either at an industry or sector level

        GC Powerlist: Turkey 2019

        The most influential and innovative in-house teams working in Turkey…

    • SUBSCRIBE TO LEGAL BUSINESS
  • Awards
      • LB Awards 2018 tablesPhotos from The Legal Business Awards
      • sponsorSponsors
      • 5DA_1362Contacts – The Legal Business Awards
  • Events
    • Previous Events


      Sicher Durch Den Sturm: Mit Weniger Mehr Erreichen – 10 December 2020

      In association with 10 December 2020, 4.00pm Mitteleuropäische Zeit

      The OpenText – Legal Business webinar – 9 December 2020

      In association with Date: 9 December 2020 Time: 4pm GMT

      Upcoming Events


      OpenText/Legal Business webinar: Reducing cost and risk: early data reconnaissance – 18 March 2021

      London, United Kingdom

      18/03/2021

      OpenText/Legal Business webinar: Early Case Assessment and Investigations: Reducing Cost and Risk (Germany) – 24 February 2021

      London, United Kingdom

      24/02/2021

      Financial Regulatory and Disputes Summit 2021

      London, United Kingdom

      01/12/2021

      All Events
  • Covid-19
International > Turkey

Turkey – Back from the brink

A ravaged economy and political tension present no significant problem for Turkey’s legal elite. They have been here before

Posted on 10 December 2019 09:30am3 February 2020 10:38am
Dominic Carman
International

A century on from Atatürk’s proclamation that the republic would be ‘happy, prosperous and victorious’, the founder of modern Turkey would today find his vision being questioned. In 2016, a failed coup left over 300 people dead. During the mass detentions that followed, nearly 2,500 judges were arrested. Within two years, Turkey’s credit bubble had burst: the lira halved in value against the US dollar, inflation hit 25% and GDP, which had been growing at 7%, flatlined.

Following the withdrawal of US troops in October 2019, the invasion of northeast Syria to create a safe zone along Turkey’s southern border led US President Donald Trump to tweet: ‘I will totally destroy and obliterate the economy of Turkey.’ In October, the House of Representatives voted by 403 to 16 to impose a series of sweeping sanctions on Turkey. But US politicians remain split, with senate majority leader Mitch McConnell warning that sanctions would cause economic damage and alienate the Turkish people. ‘It is going to be a very difficult situation for Turkey,’ notes Yasin Beceni, managing partner at Istanbul firm BTS & Partners, one of several firms that have been involved in advising Turkish clients on sanctions. ‘Because we are less familiar with the US political environment – and US firms with the Turkish legal environment – we have been in close co-operation with Covington [& Burling] in Washington,’ he says.

‘We have done a lot of work on renewables, but the high times have gone. The government has cut incentives for solar and wind.’ Orhan Yavuz Mavioğlu, ADMD

Despite the obvious trauma of recent events, domestic law firms are generally sanguine. ‘The Turkish economy is very much dependent on political circumstances,’ says Döne Yalçın, managing partner of Yalçın Babalıoğlu Boso Kemahlı. At Bezen & Partners, senior partner Yeşim Bezen concedes that the climate has fundamentally changed. ‘Three years ago, we had quite a few new investments,’ she says. ‘Activity in energy and infrastructure is still there but not at the same level. As an emerging economy, we need a lot of investment in roads, hospitals and energy, but unfortunately it is difficult for corporates, sponsors and developers to get financing in this market. Those kinds of investments have slowed down a lot.’

Feeling the strain

Turkey’s economy is highly dependent on foreign direct investment, and vulnerable, because it lacks available natural resources so has to import oil and gas. Even renewable energy is feeling the strain. ‘We have done a lot of work on renewables, but the high times have gone and it has slowed down because the government has cut some incentives, specifically for solar and wind turbines,’ says Orhan Yavuz Mavioğlu, managing partner of ADMD Law Office.

Serdar Paksoy, senior partner of Paksoy, comments: ‘Turkey is keen to bring a significant increase in its use of renewable energy in the coming years. The government is expected to announce a number of renewable energy resource zone (YEKA) tenders in the near future. These tenders should be smaller in size than the previous ones, meaning that the Turkish energy sector will offer more opportunities to a diversified group of investors.’

Pointing to ‘a multitude of issues’ facing Turkey, Timo Engelhardt, co-head of Linklaters’ Turkey practice, notes that Turkey has seen more difficult crises in the past, but refinancing has become more difficult for local companies. In addition to depressed country credit ratings from various agencies, he adds, refinancing costs and interest rates are both high while foreign exchange exposure is very difficult, particularly in US dollars. But, according to Güniz Gökçe, executive partner at White & Case, ‘every crisis creates its own opportunities’. That includes working on the major restructurings of multibillion-dollar debts in the Turkish market. ‘Debt restructuring has been extremely active and that has been an opportunity,’ she adds.

Döne Yalçın, Yalçın Babalıoğlu Boso Kemahlı

‘The government and banks are working together to develop restructuring and refinancing instruments to overcome the FX issue and protect the economy.’
Döne Yalçın, Yalçın Babalıoğlu Boso Kemahlı

Gamze Çiğdemtekin, managing partner of Çiğdemtekin Çakırca Arancı Avukatlık Ortaklığı, suggests that 2018 was ‘particularly bad – we experienced a slowdown in private consumption and investment. But things have improved because of government measures and less household demand for imports; we’ve seen export growth, especially in sectors like tourism’. Also on the upside, Fitch Ratings revised Turkey’s outlook from negative to stable in November. The inflation rate fell to 8.6% in October – its lowest level in nearly three years – although Turkey’s central bank is forecasting 12% inflation to return by January. Meanwhile, Turkey’s government has set an ambitious three-year GDP growth target of 5% per annum from 2020 onwards.

According to the treasury and finance minister, Berat Albayrak, the economy will end 2019 with positive GDP growth of 0.25%, supplemented by improving macroeconomic trends and rising economic confidence. ‘We have not seen this sort of GDP rate for the past 20 years – Turkey needs to sustain a growth rate of 5% to 6%,’ says Fethi Pekin, managing partner of Pekin & Pekin. ‘Our firm has never missed a single Eurobond issue of Turkey – more than 200 issues totalling over $100bn – and has been Turkish legal counsel to the ISDA [International Swaps and Derivatives Association] since 1998.’

In a drive to kickstart consumer growth, Turkey’s central bank has slashed benchmark rates by 7.5% since July and created incentives for banks to offer credit. Pekin takes a long-term view, noting that there was a bank run in 1995, further crises in 1998, 2001 and 2008, and another after the 2016 coup attempt. ‘It is a vicious cycle that hits the Turkish market, not because of local issues, but mainly due to international problems in the region. As a country, we are highly experienced in rebounding quickly.’

As Paksoy observes: ‘Given Turkey’s history of economic downturns followed by spectacular rebounds, some investment advisers also see the current period as offering attractive valuations for buyers with the prospect of sizeable returns when the market recovers.’

Nevertheless, the negative impact on M&A and foreign direct investment has been significant. Hopes were raised by Volkswagen (VW)’s plan to build a €1.3bn plant in Turkey, but the project was put on hold following the military offensive in Syria. Linklaters has been advising VW on the new plant. ‘VW is a sophisticated multinational: it’s not going to enter a new market unless it thinks it’s going to make money,’ says Kerem Turunç, managing partner of TURUNÇ.

Yeşim Bezen, Bezen & Partners

‘Whereas we have had a lot of US and European interest in the past, we might get more Asian or Russian interest in future because of their risk appetite.’
Yeşim Bezen, Bezen & Partners

It is no surprise that charge-out rates have come under pressure. Some lawyers suggest that fees in the Turkish market can still go up to $550-$600 an hour. But apart from premium work, that may be wishful thinking. One senior partner of a local firm says: ‘If I were to quote for a decent M&A deal and then be paid less than $100k, then it is not really viable.’ Another comments: ‘Rates are very much lower. Turkish companies will benefit in the short term, but if this results in clients getting used to low fee levels, we will struggle. In the end, we will not be in a position to deliver quality over time.’

According to Mergermarket, Turkish M&A did manage a notable revival last year. Despite the low number of deals, there was a 40% increase in aggregate value compared to 2017: 83 deals worth €10.3bn. This total was boosted by two standout deals – the €2.7bn acquisition of Denizbank by Emirates NBD Bank and the €1.9bn acquisition of a 55% stake in Türk Telekom by Levent Yapılandırma Yönetimi (LYY). Paksoy advised Sberbank of Russia, which owns Denizbank, while Clifford Chance advised Emirates NBD. On the Türk Telekom deal, Esin Attorney Partnership (Baker McKenzie) advised LYY while the sellers instructed Allen & Overy.

‘The Turkish market is highly attractive for potential M&A transactions,’ says Yalçin. ‘The government and local banks are working together to develop restructuring and refinancing instruments to overcome the FX issue and protect the economy.’ So far, no billion-dollar deals have taken place in Turkey this year. ‘The first three quarters were slow,’ notes Resat Moral, managing partner of Moral & Partners.

Countercyclical

In difficult times, some sectors still attract attention. Internet, mobile telecoms services and technology have been the standout areas by volume with 50 and 45 deals, respectively, over the last two years. Elsewhere, financial services, food and beverage, manufacturing, infrastructure, logistics, transportation and media sectors have also seen significant M&A activity. One of the largest deals in 2019 involved Qatari investment firm Mayhoola raising its stake in Turkish luxury department store Beymen. ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law advised Beymen on the $405m sale. ‘Big-ticket deals are very rare at the moment,’ says the firm’s founding partner Gönenç Gürkaynak. The slowdown takes a toll on negotiations and the structuring of transactions, he adds. ‘We don’t see companies abandoning their Turkey plans entirely, because it is a tremendous market with a young population and huge potential for all kinds of business, but they tend to be conservative and take things slowly.’

Competition work remains reasonably buoyant, comprising over half of ELIG Gürkaynak’s practice. ‘One third of our merger control work comes from international law firms’ referrals,’ says Gürkaynak. ‘In competition law, advisory work is about 25%, while defence and merger control work take the remaining 75% equally.’

Looking ahead, M&A activity in major infrastructure – notably ports – is forecast by White & Case. ‘There have been some arrangers instructed for certain major assets that are going to come up in 2020,’ says Gökçe. ‘We also see some distribution assets, interestingly on the energy side, and international investors looking at electricity grids and natural gas distribution assets.’ In terms of future inbound investment, Yalçin points to manufacturing, technology, medical devices, entertainment (fast food), payment systems, energy (alternative fuels) and real estate as the areas of greatest interest.

Bezen has noted a shift in the geographic profile of investors. ‘Whereas we have had a lot of US and European interest in the past, we might get more Asian or Russian interest in future because of their risk appetite. Turkey is probably a more attractive market for Asian and CIS investors who are less risk averse.’ Yazıcı Avukatlık Ortaklığı’s founding partner, Murat Yazıcı, agrees: ‘The profile of M&A in Turkey has changed from western capital to Middle East and eastern capital – Qatar, India and China increasingly take part in Turkish M&A deals.’

In summarising the current challenges, Jonathan Blythe, partner at Senguler & Senguler, speaks for many of his Turkish counterparts: ‘It used to be that you would get M&A deals and that was great. You worked hard, earned good money and could charge good rates. Now, there are far fewer deals so we’ve had to adapt our business and develop a different long-term strategy.’ Part of that involves doing more litigation and ‘seeking to provide day-to-day business law support for a whole range of businesses.’

Gönenç Gürkaynak, ELIG Gürkaynak

‘We don’t see companies abandoning their Turkey plans entirely, but they tend to be conservative and take things slowly.’
Gönenç Gürkaynak, ELIG Gürkaynak

Project and infrastructure development remain integral to the government’s long-term strategy and are a perennial source of work for the legal sector. To be funded by a $200bn decade-long investment plan, President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan made it a priority during his 2018 election campaign, promising a raft of infrastructure mega-projects to celebrate the 2023 centenary of the Turkish republic.

These include the new $12bn Istanbul Airport – at 76.5 sq km, six times the area of Heathrow. When completed in 2027, it should be the world’s busiest by some margin: six runways and four terminals will have capacity to accommodate 200 million passengers a year. However, the International Monetary Fund has sounded a note of caution, urging ‘strict selection’ on project expenditure.

‘Because these infrastructure projects are supported by the government, they are less impacted by economic problems, although they are not immune,’ says Çiğdemtekin. ‘The government is very ambitious about infrastructure and will carry on supporting them, so we will continue to see legal work coming from that space.’

White & Case has been engaged on the financing of Istanbul Airport, advising banks and other financial institutions. Also high on the government’s project list is the mile-long Yavuz Sultan Selim bridge, commonly known as the third bridge, which spans the Bosphorus and is the world’s largest in its class. The $3bn project provides an eight-lane route for the Istanbul-Izmir highway. ‘We have been focusing on the investor side with some existing infrastructure deals which are looking to refinance, like the third bridge,’ says Gökçe. ‘We are also working on a number of healthcare PPP projects, some with additional phases coming back to refinance. Because they are now operational, they are trying to see if they can attract a new business investor base, looking at potential bond issues.’

Compliance is another practice area that remains largely immune from economic difficulties. Most notable is The Turkish Data Protection Law, comparable in part to GDPR, which was introduced in 2018. Yalçin notes that it creates obligations for Turkish companies, such as preparing data privacy notices and consent forms, and registering with the Turkish data controller. In some cases, companies need to restructure their business processes to comply, which requires significant effort and investment in legal and IT services, which is good news for lawyers. Beceni adds: ‘We have a huge team doing compliance projects and providing advice on data privacy to local and multinational companies doing business in Turkey.’ BTS signed a co-operation agreement with Bird & Bird in 2014 but now operates as an independent firm.

‘It used to be that you would get M&A deals and that was great. You could charge good rates. Now, there are far fewer deals so we’ve had to develop a different strategy.’ Jonathan Blythe, Senguler & Senguler

Unshakeable optimism

To the outside observer, Turkey undoubtedly appears to be a very challenging jurisdiction – for both domestic and foreign players. The need for significant rationalisation in the number of local commercial law firms is evident in a market dominated by small partnerships comprising no more than 100 lawyers. For the market to mature, a rash of mergers would seem to be inevitable (see ‘Ripe for consolidation’). But the 30-year narrative of the Turkish legal elite endures – that despite the economy and business climate being buffeted by various headwinds, solutions are found and the country moves forward.

Bezen characterises this optimistic outlook. ‘When stability returns, then we will see M&A deals flourishing again. We are hoping that there will be a boom again in projects and M&A, and with that comes finance: you need financing for all those investments. We will become busy again – as busy as we were three years ago. It’s exciting for a lawyer to be involved in a new investment, a new business and a complicated finance deal.’

The caveat is ‘when stability returns’. For now, the Turkish legal market will have to persist with its customary resilience as one problem hits after another. LB

Click here for sponsored briefings on Turkey.

Ripe for consolidation: an oversaturated legal market

According to Human Rights Watch, 1,546 Turkish lawyers have been prosecuted over the failed 2016 coup attempt: more than 600 of them are in prison. Meanwhile, local lawyers who represent clients accused of terrorism offences have themselves become targets for prosecution and arbitrary detention. Yet none of this has prevented young graduates from entering the legal profession in droves. Quite the contrary – a record number have qualified in the past year.

One positive is that there are now many more women lawyers: in the latest available data, 42,476 in 2016 compared to 18,947 in 2006. Over the same period, the number of male lawyers increased from 38,605 to 57,985. Added to this are more than 10,000 newly-qualified lawyers. ‘We have a vast number of lawyers being manufactured by law schools. They may not be able to find sufficient work because the market is not growing at the same rate,’ says Orhan Yavuz Mavioğlu, managing partner of ADMD Law Office. Izgi Genc, a senior recruiter at Taylor Root, says: ‘There are so many lawyers, which makes it difficult for us to find the right talent for law firms.’

Turkey is certainly awash with law firms and no large players dominate the market. Gamze Çiğdemtekin, managing partner of Çiğdemtekin Çakırca Arancı Avukatlık Ortaklığı, observes that there are still a lot of family firms: ‘Couples and siblings working in the same firm, and second or third-generation lawyers who have inherited the firm from their fathers and grandfathers. It’s changing gradually towards more corporate firm structures.’

At ELIG Gürkaynak, one of Turkey’s largest firms with 90 lawyers, founding partner Gönenç Gürkaynak says: ‘In this kind of environment, you are not able to grow safely beyond a certain size – it’s too risky. You would be front-loading and too highly leveraging the operation if you were to do that.’

The Turkish legal profession still lacks sophisticated governance, according to Mehmet Gün, managing partner of Gün + Partners. ‘Firms are often 20 or 30 lawyers; those that employ more than 50 lawyers are exceptional because they struggle with growth and scale problems,’ he says. ‘Managing over 100 lawyers is almost impossible by Turkish standards.’

Kerem Turunç, managing partner of TURUNÇ, agrees. ‘Turkey probably has twice as many firms as it should for the market to be sufficiently profitable,’ he says. ‘The Turkish market is very competitive and the concept of a partnership is still a cultural enigma.’ He argues that consolidation and mergers need to happen, ‘but it’s going to take younger generations assuming management positions’.

More lawyers and less premium work have inevitably combined to create a squeeze in rates. Umit Baser, general counsel of EYG, says: ‘Law firm fees are very changeable in Turkey. Most of them do not charge by the hour.’ Jonathan Blythe, partner at Senguler & Senguler, comments: ‘It’s rare that people agree to an hourly rate. Most of the time, they want a capped fee. A blended rate of $250 per hour would be seen as relatively high, especially in the current environment.’

At Bezen & Partners, senior partner Yeşim Bezen says: ‘When you don’t get as many mandates for new investments, then prices go down and competition rises. There is a lot of splitting up among partnerships and a mushrooming of new law firms.’ Timo Engelhardt, head of Linklaters’ Turkey practice, concludes: ‘The Turkish legal market is suffering from a deterioration of fees. Rates have gone down and there will be some form of self-regulation of the local market.’

Fruits of chaos: dispute resolution in Turkey

‘Commercial disputes are on the rise,’ says Yunus Çağlar, counsel at Herdem. Most often, these are a by-product of the lira’s sharp devaluation with disputes in energy, infrastructure, technology, media and telecoms being especially prevalent. ‘Very few in-house departments employ lawyers to manage litigation internally: the process is far too time-consuming with little added value,’ says Hakan Bekiroğlu, chief legal officer of Tofas.

‘Turkish companies have suffered terribly, particularly those in foreign trade and import,’ says Döne Yalçin, managing partner of Yalçın Babalıoğlu Boso Kemahlı Law Firm in cooperation with CMS. ‘Recent economic instability has resulted in plenty of disputes work covering enforcement, employment, bankruptcy and insolvency, liquidation, company restructuring and reorganisation.’

Such disputes are increasing because of an inability to pay debts – not because of bad faith, but because the economy has turned, according to Kerem Turunç, managing partner of TURUNÇ. ‘We are usually on the other side of the table when it comes to insolvencies, bankruptcies or restructurings. Our clients unfortunately end up being the victims of their counterparties’ restructuring or insolvency situations.’

Although many law firms report an increase in disputes work, litigation in Turkey is problematic. Turkish courts are infamous for lengthy proceedings: ‘Cases continue forever,’ says Mehmet Gün, managing partner of Gün + Partners. ‘Our experience is that judges deliver the right verdict,’ says Turunç. ‘The problem is that delayed justice may not be justice at all, because you may not have three years to wait for the process to run its course.’

Yazıcı Avukatlık Ortaklığı’s founding partner, Murat Yazıcı, observes that some western investors perceive the rule of law to be a problem in Turkey. That is putting it mildly. Following the 2016 attempted coup, 40% of Turkey’s judiciary was purged. ‘They were replaced with new judges who are very young and inexperienced, which is causing a lot of problems and they are trying to find solutions,’ says Gün.

One solution is mediation. New government regulations have made mediation mandatory for employment and commercial disputes before a court case is filed. ‘It started with employment disputes in 2018 with the same system introduced in 2019 for commercial cases,’ says Jonathan Blythe, partner at Senguler & Senguler. ‘It’s had a filter effect on employment disputes: 50-60% have settled at mediation or did not go to full litigation, which has helped to reduce the caseloads and allow younger judges who are struggling to gain more experience before cases come to them.’

Nevertheless, parties in Turkish disputes generally refrain from domestic court proceedings. Beyond the factors of time and inexperienced judges, there is additional concern over their lack of independence and impartiality. Arbitration is the obvious alternative. The Istanbul Arbitration Centre, established in October 2015, provides time and cost savings, according to Bahar Daniş, senior partner of Matur & Ökten & Karayel Keßler Law Office. However, ‘Turkey is promoting its own arbitration centre, but we haven’t seen it really materialise,’ notes Linklaters partner Timo Engelhardt. ‘Turks like to go to Switzerland, so arbitration often ends up in Geneva or Zurich,’ he says.

International arbitration appears to be the only viable solution, rather than using local dispute resolution. Yeşim Bezen, senior partner of Bezen & Partners adds: ‘It’s unfair on the judges because they are put there without real training and they need to deal with a large number of cases. We are advising clients to agree to arbitration. We do a lot of institutional arbitration before the ICC or LCIA.’

But inevitably there is always some scope for optimism for those lawyers engaged in local disputes locally. ‘If Turkey gets into serious financial trouble – and right now I don’t foresee it, but if it deepens further – then litigation will increase dramatically and that’s where you start to make money,’ says Fethi Pekin, managing partner of Pekin & Pekin.

+1
Tweet
Share
Share
Pin
  • Subscriber Login

  • Latest Issue

    LB300 cover

    • 300 not out…the story of Legal Business spanning three decades
    • The Euro Elite 2021: Keeping the cogs turning
    • The Euro Elite overview: Enduring endurance
    • The Euro Elite: Main Table
    • Getting personal – perspectives on crisis management in the Covid-19 era
    • Leader: Learning from the ghosts of decades past
    • Pritchard: Depressing end to Weinstein gagging order narrative means closure for none
    • Life During Law: Anu Balasubramanian
    • The Legal 500 View: The rise of US firms from barbarians at the gate to London’s top tiers
  • Sponsored Briefings

    • Sponsored briefing: Growing interest in asset deals

      Yegan Liaje of Pekin & Pekin describes a rising interest in asset deals following a period of economic uncertainty in Turkey Turkey has faced some serious financial challenges in recent years, such as high inflation, currency collapse and rising borrowing costs; however, surprisingly, these challenges have not dramatically affected the Turkish M&A market in terms of total…

    • Sponsored briefing: Economic crisis and the popularisation of voluntary termination of labour contracts

      Murat Uyanık of Yavuz & Uyanık discusses Turkish labour law developments Turkey’s progress towards full membership of the EU had gained pace by the beginning of the 2000s. To achieve full legislative alignment with the EU acquis, the Turkish labour law was renewed and a new concept was introduced to the country’s labour law sphere:…

    • Sponsored briefing: A leader in competition law

      Led by Gönenç Gürkaynak, ELIG Gürkaynak’s competition practice has wide expertise in Turkish antitrust law ELIG Gürkaynak Attorneys-at-Law is an eminent, independent Turkish law firm based in Istanbul. The firm was founded in 2005. ELIG Gürkaynak is committed to providing its clients with high-quality legal services. We combine a solid knowledge of Turkish law with…

    • Sponsored briefing: Med-arb: a hybrid approach to ADR and its applicability in Turkey

      Matur & Ökten’s Bahar Nalan Danış discusses combining mediation and arbitration Today’s world is changing at a dazzling speed, and so is the way we deal with disputes. Although originating from thousands of years ago, we may well state that alternative dispute resolution (ADR) in its modern meaning was developed in the 20th century and…

    • Sponsored briefing: New practice commenced in 2019 – current status of mandatory mediation in commercial lawsuits

      Mehmet Selim Yavuz of Yavuz & Uyanık discusses the effects of the new rules Prior to 2016, the Court of Cassation was the only high court reviewing rulings of the courts of first instance. This led to an enormous workload for the court; hence final rulings could only be reached after a seriously long period…

    • Sponsored briefing: Turkey M&A outlook: 2020 and beyond

      Gamze Çiğdemtekin (pictured, left) and İpek Batum (pictured, right) of Çiğdemtekin Çakırca Arancı assess what lies ahead for the deals market over the next few years Global economic uncertainties have affected the M&A market, and the recession in the Turkish market was as expected for 2019. According to the data reported on M&A transactions in…

    • Sponsored briefing: Notable developments in Turkey’s oil and gas policy

      Yazıcı’s Kerem Arıç explores three key areas of growth for the country’s energy sector Due to its dependence on oil and natural gas imports, Turkey has been in need of structural changes in its energy sector. Although the share of natural gas in power generation was significantly reduced in 2019, the overall reliance on natural…

    • Sponsored briefing: Mediation on the rise in Turkey

      Eda Cerrahoğlu Balssen (pictured, left) and Sezin Dündar (pictured, right) of Cerrahoğlu discuss the legal requirement for mandatory mediation in commercial disputes Turkey was introduced to mediation in 2012 with the adoption of Law No. 6325 on Mediation in Legal Disputes (Mediation Law), which regulates the mechanism of voluntary mediation. After implementing voluntary mediation for…

    • Sponsored briefing: Notable developments in construction law and practice

      Yazıcı’s Bilge Müftüoğlu on the effect of government incentives on the energy sector There are major criteria that investors consider in advance of determining the type and extent of their investment in any sector and the energy sector is no different. Incentives granted by states are one of these as they have considerable impact on…

    • Sponsored briefing: Termination of distributorship agreements

      Ecem Yıldırım of Apak Uras outlines how distributorship agreements are dealt with under Turkish law a) General explanations We are living in a world where, day by day, customers’ demands for more products that are not manufactured in their own countries increase. Furthermore, the continuing growth in the financial world has also led businesses to…

    • Sponsored briefing: Restrictive measures against Turkey by the EU

      Vona Law Firm’s Gül Özdinç sets out a criticism of the European Council’s new regulation concerning restrictions on Turkey The European Council adopted a framework for restrictive measures against Turkey for its drilling activities in the Eastern Mediterranean with Regulation (EU) No 2019/1890 of 11 November 2019. The framework will make it possible to sanction…

    • Sponsored briefing: Obligation to register before the Turkish data controllers registry and maintain personal data-processing inventory

      Yasin Beceni and Susen Aklan of BTS clarify Turkey’s data protection regulations on data controller registry obligations Article 16 of Law no. 6698 on the Protection of Personal Data (DP Law) introduced a general obligation on data controllers to register before the Data Controllers Registry that is to be maintained by the Turkish Data Protection…

    • Sponsored briefing: Life sciences in Turkey

      Özge Atılgan Karakulak and Dicle Doğan of Gün + Partners explain how the country’s growing healthcare and pharma industries operate under current regulations Having a population of 80 million covered by an extensive social healthcare system, Turkey’s life sciences industry is still important in size and volume. Both the Turkish pharma and medical device industries…

    • Sponsored briefing: Q&A – Serdar Paksoy

      1. Given Turkey’s recent economic problems, how is this affecting your clients and how can you help mitigate the risks? Turkey has been going through a period of economic uncertainty since the summer of 2018, when a number of factors led to a sharp devaluation of the Turkish lira against major foreign currencies and a…

    • Sponsored briefing: Q&A – Vefa Resat Moral

      How would you describe the current state of the Turkish legal market? In two words, ‘fragile’ and ‘optimistic’. For the last half decade Turkey has been busy with national security, all types of elections, geopolitical developments and positioning, global mind games and, consequently, a recessed economy. Such uncontrollable developments are naturally pressing on business law…

  • Related by topic

    UK offshore report: Staying afloat
  • Most read this week

    1. Revolving doors: A&O enters La La Land with group hire as DLA Piper lures former Freshfields finance chief
    2. In-house: New Merlin Entertainments GC launches first-ever formal panel
    3. Race to the top: Baker McKenzie promotes 80 new global partners and elects German managing partner
    4. DLA builds up African presence with Tunisia and Senegal firm buyouts
    5. Cleary, CC and Covington lead as EC fine Google €2.4bn for abuse of dominance in online shopping comparison

    Analysis

    • LB300 – issue menu

    • Access your print copy online – LB300

    • 300 not out…the story of Legal Business spanning three decades

    • The Euro Elite 2021: Keeping the cogs turning

    • The Euro Elite overview: Enduring endurance

    • Euro Elite: Baltics – Small yet spirited

    • Euro Elite: Benelux – Reasons to be cheerful

    Useful Links

    • The Legal 500
    • GC Magazine
    • GC Powerlist
    • In-house Lawyer Magazine
    • The Lex 100
    • Legalease Law Journals
    • Legalease Publishing
    • Tax Directors Handbook
    • Practical Lawyer

    © 2021 Legal Business Magazine

    Legalease Ltd, 188 Fleet Street, London, EC4A 2AG

    T: +44 (0)20 7396 9313 | E: subscriptions@legalease.co.uk

    About & Contacts | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Subscriptions